Multiple insurance policies can still lead to gaps in your coverage.

When one policy excludes a particular exposure, purchasing separate coverage may seem like a simple way to close the gap. 

But what happens when the policies don’t work together as expected? 

True claims scenario: A health services organization faced a claim after an employee alleged inappropriate physical contact by a disabled individual receiving his care. At the same time, the employee also raised several employment-related complaints, including scheduling issues and denied breaks, in his claim. 

On paper, the organization has employment practices liability insurance (EPLI) that covers employment-related claims. Because this policy contains a known sexual abuse and molestation (SAM) exclusion, the organization has a separate SAM policy. 

When the organization submits a claim for this incident, the EPLI carrier cites its SAM exclusion, interprets the policy language, and denies coverage for the entire claim. 

The SAM carrier takes a different position. It determines that the alleged conduct doesn’t meet its policy’s definition of sexual abuse and also declines coverage for all allegations. The employment practices allegations also fall outside the scope of the SAM policy. Despite purchasing two policies to address different exposures, the organization faces a substantial settlement demand and legal expenses without the insurance protection it expected. 

Insurance coverage gaps aren’t always the result of not purchasing the right policy. Sometimes they emerge from how exclusions, definitions, and coverage triggers interact across multiple policies.

 

4 Key Considerations for Avoiding Coverage Gaps

Human services organizations must look beyond policy premiums and limits to uncover their coverage gaps. While cost, deductibles, and coverage limits are important, they don't tell the full story. Evaluate how policies would respond to realistic claims scenarios of your organization, particularly those involving multiple allegations. 

Follow these four best practices:

  1. Exclusions are complex. 
    Sexual abuse and molestation (SAM) exclusions are common in liability policies, like employment practices liability insurance (EPLI). Depending on the wording, these exclusions may affect coverage for other allegations included in the same claim. Common exclusionary language can appear in surplus lines policies, for example, which are often used to insure businesses with complex exposures or challenging claims histories. 
  2. Evaluate policies together, never in isolation. 
    When multiple policies are intended to address related or overlapping exposures, review how their definitions, exclusions, and coverage triggers interact. Depending on the wording, an allegation of misconduct can potentially eliminate coverage for other allegations included in the same complaint. Whenever multiple policies are intended to address overlapping exposures, differences in policy wording can create unexpected gaps.
  3. Operational changes = change in coverage. 
    As your organization expands to serve new populations, or changes how, where and when it operates, revisit your insurance program to ensure it addresses your evolving exposures.
  4. Keep descriptions of services consistent. 
    Review how your organization's operations are described in insurance applications, policies, on your website and in all public materials. These can all be used as evidence in a claim. Discrepancies could leave you exposed.


Work with your broker today

An experienced broker’s value lies in understanding your operations, recognizing overlapping coverage exposures, and identifying potential policy gaps. They will ensure your portfolio of policies works in tandem to protect your organization, regardless of the claim, against the complex risks you face. 

 

Consult a Venbrook Risk Advisor

The right coverage goes beyond having multiple policies. Let’s talk about your organization’s risk exposures.

Thomas Perkins
Vice President, Property & Casualty 
CA License 0547496
tperkins@venbrook.com